Brandy Melville- a one-size-fits-small, body-shaming brand
Brandy Melville, initially a European Brand that moved to the United States in 2009, advertises a one-size-fits-all clothing brand. Their contemporary apparel follows the latest trends on Instagram, so their selection is always in style, cool, and most importantly, affordable. Now that we are in high school we all have to know about the infamous Brandy Melville, because of its staple in teen American girl wardrobe.
Brandy’s advertisement consists of posting on Instagram and word of mouth. They chose photos of the “prettiest, skinniest, long-legged, thin waisted, white, blonde” girls to post on their platform. Conveniently setting a standard for their desired target audience.
In 7th grade, I finally graduated from tight skinny khaki pants to the khaki skirt that you would roll once on your waist, just enough to get away with a skirt above your fingertips. I started wearing polos and stopped wearing my uncle’s Doctor Who jacket. Instead, I wore the same Frank Black Middle School crewneck that everyone else wore. But finally, I was accepted into the cool girl group. Mind you- I didn’t know this at the time- the cool girl group consisted of white skinny blonde girls who already wore faces painted with makeup every day to school. Obviously, I needed to get to work on my mascara abilities, or actually look into buying mascara. They all sat around me at lunch, and I was surrounded with the same small tight cropped ribbed tank tops with a tiny bow in the middle of the neckline in a variety of 5 different neutral tones. I needed to own one of these tops.
Blissfully, I walked into a store named Brandy Melville, I loved every single top in sight and handed as many as I could to my mom. They were all in style and exactly what I should be wearing to stay in the cool-girl club. Lots of spaghetti straps, cropped tanks, flower patterns, butterflies, baggy jeans… exactly what I needed to fit in. My mom, being a mom, checked the sizes to make sure I was picking the right ones. “These all say ONE SIZE,” she said. This meant that I had to be the same size as my friends or smaller, but I didn’t want to be able to compare my body to my friends, knowing that they all fit in these tops and I might not.
No way on Earth I was trying anything on. I was humiliated. I ignored my mom, walking out of the store while she followed behind me. Once I was safe and sound inside of the tinted car, I started bawling. The biggest size is a small? How were the girls in there so tiny? Even the older workers fit into those doll-size clothes.
After a good 10 minutes of crying, my mom wiped the sticky tears off my cheeks, and peeled my booger-filled hair off my chin. We left. We were done with that store.
Sizing is limited to one size and so are their employees. The only people allowed to work in their store must fit the perfect American girl doll standard. An employee named Callie explains her experience there to the entire internet exposing the inner racism instilled through the brand.
She turned in a resume from a candidate that wanted to try out for a job at the store. She brought the resume to her employer. After a couple of glances, he looked up and asked for her race. “Asian,” Callie said. With no further inspection she was turned down and told to look for a new job.
Since middle school, I have returned to the store and bought a couple of items. Sad to say, I have never seen an employee of any other race than white. The shirts that I unfortunately bought all had a stretchy waist but the cuffs on the arms were made for a 2-year-old. I literally had to rip mine a little bit to comfortably wear them. So I would recommend getting a top with spaghetti straps, so you don’t lose circulation in your arms.
Their pants are a different story; you either fit or you don’t. There is no stretch. The length of the legs are also made for shorter people so if you’re over 5’6 then most of their pants will stop above your ankles.
Walking into a store with unrealistic expectations to fit into a basic t-shirt made for a 6-year-old as an 18-year-old, is an impossible standard for anyone barely over a size 4. I am sad to say that I have bought 4 clothing items from them when I was in a haze of “oh my gosh I’m small enough for this store I need to buy it all.” But now I am proud to say I will never support a racist and body-shaming company. Honestly, the best thing you could get from the store are the free stickers!
Your donation will support the student journalists of Carnegie Vanguard High School. Your contribution will allow us to cover our annual website hosting costs and fund field trips, competition fees, and equipment. We appreciate your support!
Hi, I'm a senior. I am a feature story editor and i have the best dog in the world.
Sofia Hegstrom • Nov 16, 2021 at 10:20 am
So relatable, I’m really glad you mentioned the racism of the brand– scrolling through their socials is pretty depressing. Thank you for writing this
Caitlin Liman • Nov 9, 2021 at 11:59 pm
Wow- the way you denounced their discriminatory behaviors with intimate anecdotes and narrative language was exemplary. And I never knew that this existed! Love the insightful review, Julian :]
Brooke Ferrell • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:15 pm
I really enjoyed how honest you were about this brand. It was a really good look into problems they perpetuate.
Alex Samano • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:12 pm
This article is really interesting. I have never really looked into Brandy Melville too much, but I can relate to the experiences you had. It was very well articulated too.
Ava Lim • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:08 pm
I loved the line where you introduced how both the company’s clothing and their employees weren’t diverse – “Sizing is limited to one size and so are their employees.” It was also refreshing to see you talk about buying from the store and how you felt about it whilst acknowledging and condemning their bigotry. Most of us only do the latter, but to talk about the former brings a more relatable take on issues like these!
Nicki Birangi • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:07 pm
I love how you talked about your experience in middle school!
Isabel Hoffman • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:03 pm
I really appreciated the perspective of the story as it was critical but not “mean”.
Danielle Yampuler • Nov 9, 2021 at 2:02 pm
I love this story, really exposes the crappiness of the brand on a personal level.
Abigail Nunez • Nov 9, 2021 at 1:59 pm
It sucks how young teenage girls mentalities with their own body can be so drastically affected by other people’s say in what is trending. I really liked this story because it gives an example of what some girls might feel through your own experience .
hannah mansour • Nov 9, 2021 at 1:58 pm
I love the title SO MUCH. I related to your perspective so much especially since in middle school I could not fit into the clothes either. I also like how you bring light into the ongoing problems.
MyTran Vo • Nov 9, 2021 at 1:57 pm
I liked how you added media from the company and described how they can effect the mindset of everyone who views it