Op-Ed: The reality in 2D
It’s not unusual for livestream chats to fly by faster than interpretable, most viewers only managing a fragment of understanding in regards to the dozens of conversations happening simultaneously. However, this wasn’t the case for a series of livestreams by Guiniang (龟娘) as her chat was composed entirely by an onslaught of uniform hatred, snuffing out any semblance of casual conversation.
Guiniang is a Chinese voice actress who’s known best for her work in Kimetsu no Yaiba, Boku no Hero Academia, and most recently, Genshin Impact, where she voices the character Sangonomiya Kokomi.
The initial fanfare for Kokomi’s debut was nothing in comparison to the massive tidal wave of disappointment and hatered that followed the character’s official release due to skills that left the community unsatisfied.
Following this, a stream Guiniang held was swarmed by people holding her accountable for the character’s combat weaknesses, despite Guiniang having no part in the character’s creation. Harassment, insults, and threats deluged her stream – so much so that she had to limit who could speak in her chat with a mass-member mute.
“We’re normal people with jobs that we do our best on,” tweeted Zach Aguilar, another voice actor for Genshin Impact. He’s voiced dozens of popular characters in the past, such as Tanjiro Kamado in Kimetsu no Yaiba. “I know the voice actors are the ones in the public eye a lot of the time – but there’s a lot that goes on behind the scenes out of our control.”
Laura Stahl, known best for her role in The Promised Neverland, was bashed after announcing that she’d be voicing Mami Nanami in the anime Rent-A-Girlfriend – a character greatly despised by the community.
Due to this role, Stahl received private messages and public “call-out” posts where she was relentlessly insulted.
And much like how Guiniang and Laura Stahl have been attacked, many other voice actors receive a similar treatment because of their presentation or identity.
“I have been fortunate to avoid most negativity and harassment on social media, but I think many others have it much worse,” stated Cory Yee, a voice actor who’s best known for his role in Genshin Impact as Gorou. “I’ve seen my peers face all sorts of harassment on social media, and it baffles me constantly. Many women, feminine presenting, or feminine of center people get harassed more than I do by a long shot.”
Occasionally, the harassment even leaks beyond the screen, threatening the lives of people simply doing their jobs.
“There was a certain project that I was working on, and a fan who was unhappy with the direction that the story was going actually went into the headquarters with a weapon and had to be escorted off by the police because they were putting people in the company in danger,” said Stephanie Southerland, known for her roles in Fire Emblem Heroes and Genshin Impact as Jean. “It’s just scary thinking that people get that attached to things and feel that kind of ownership over something.”
Despite all of the harassment or bullying voice actors receive, voice actors always find ways to not only enjoy their jobs, but also the communities that continue to support them.
“In this particularly uncertain time, people turn to the arts for escapism or to see or play as a character who may embody something they want in their lives. It’s always an honor to be able to tell a story that people want to experience,” said Yee.
During the global pandemic, social media sites like TikTok and Twitter saw a huge rise in popularity, and connections between voice actors and their audiences grew prevalent.
“The fan engagement brings me back to my childhood days and being imaginative and fearless,” stated Griffin Burns, a voice actor most known for his work in Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure as Doppio and Genshin Impact as Tartaglia. He has a significant following on his TikTok and Twitter and has become an icon of the communities he’s worked for. “I’ve gotten so much support for my antics that I feel like I’m able to be my authentic, goofy self, and it’s pretty liberating,”
Sean Chiplock, known best for his work in Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure and his upcoming role in Marvel’s Avengers, is another voice actor who often interacts with his audience.
“Part of the reason I look forward to conventions so much is because it was one of the easiest ways to show everyone who visits me that despite me being ‘a celebrity’, I am hardly any different from them.”
While interactions between voice actors and fandoms can be heartwarming, the issue of harassment still stands as a topic that needs to be addressed and resolved. The discretion between the online world and real life seems to become blurrier every day, the wariness of the differences between voice actors and their characters still being an unknown for people who choose to harass these creators.
“These are wonderful worlds that we get to be a part of as voice actors, and it’s wonderful to be able to escape reality, but you still have to keep that head on your shoulders and know what is real and what is a pretend world,” stated Southerland.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Carnegie Vanguard High School. Your contribution will allow us to cover our annual website hosting costs and fund field trips, competition fees, and equipment. We appreciate your support!
Nadia is a senior at CVHS in her 4th year of writing for the Upstream. She has been writing as a hobby and competitively for nearly a decade and her favorite...
Julian Namerow • Feb 1, 2022 at 2:17 pm
I loved the story but I was honestly a little confused at the beginning because I didn’t understand who this person was. But this was a great story I love that you picked to write about this.
Jessica • Feb 1, 2022 at 2:07 pm
This was a very interesting article. I hadn’t known about this abuse, and I appreciated how you included many examples.
Judith Carrizales • Feb 1, 2022 at 11:36 am
This is an amazing article. Good job on the interviews. It’s really sad that people don’t see the fine line between the character and the actor. 🙂